So, in celebration of the arrival of two exceptional Osteopaths to the OC team - Andrew Hudson and Anna Aydinc (see below to find out their specialisms) I thought I would spread light on this commonly asked question.
The quick answer is that an experienced Chartered Physiotherapist and an experienced Registered Osteopath who are clinically excellent will provide very similar assessment and treatment and BOTH treat back pain as part of their core expertise. The differences if any at this stage come down to personal experience - what the individual clinician has chosen to specialise in over the years. It is therefore worth reading the individual bio of a clinician to make a decision on who you want to see, or, in the case of Octopus Clinic, to ask our admin team who they would advise you see,
The other important note is that if you are not recovering at the speed you thought you would then it is ALWAYS worth getting a second opinion and any decent Physiotherapist or Osteopath experienced enough to have confidence in their own ability will not be offended or concerned that you are doing so. At Octopus Clinic, we seek second opinions from other members of the team all the time, that is one of the joys of working with a twelve-strong bunch of experienced clinicians. Check out my article on 'Second opinions - scary or sacred?'
However, there are a few differences that are worth noting and they come from training background. Both Physiotherapists and Osteopaths assess, diagnose and treat pain or dysfunction of the neuromusculoskeletal system including muscles, joints, bones, nerves, ligaments and tendons. Both are trained in the anatomy, physiology, pathology and biomechanics of the whole body, not just of the musculoskeletal system.
As part of their 3-4 year degree or masters, Physiotherapists train in all the areas of physiotherapy (orthopaedics, respiratory, neurological, elderly care, cardio, medical, intensive care, paediatrics and sometimes other specialisms like hands, burns and mental health) before specialising in 'musculoskeletal' which goes hand in hand with 'sports' physiotherapy. Historically, Physiotherapists would spend at least a couple of years on the NHS after graduation before moving into private practice but with the cut backs on the NHS this is not necessarily the case now. The undergraduate training for Physiotherapists focuses on exercise based medicine and movement facilitation with a strong bias on the patient becoming independent. Basic manual techniques are taught at university but most are learnt post-graduate level in the form of courses and in house training.
In the 3-4 year osteopathy degree or masters there is far more training in manual techniques with a strong focus on joint manipulation, visceral treatments and the spine and pelvis. Basic lower limb biomechanics is taught but most lower limb and upper limb movement patterning, exercise based medicine and post-operative rehab is learned at post graduate level.
If this is confusing you even more well let me give you a personal example. As an experienced Physiotherapist, if I think a patient needs a joint manipulating (which is a fast sudden movement involving a crack) and/or I need a second opinion on a pelvis and/or I suspect something visceral going on, I will often refer to my osteopath colleagues. I also know that Hazel, an experienced Osteopath, will refer to me if she wants a second opinion on biomechanics, movement patterning and high level rehab. However, I also refer to my fellow physio colleagues for second opinions and I know that she does the same with her fellow osteos.
So here are our new Osteopaths, please do not hesitate to get in touch if you would like further information and don't forget our 10% refer a friend promotion!
All the best,
Since gaining his Masters of Osteopathy Andrew gained extensive experience working in a number of Melbourne’s most reputable clinics and learning from some of Australia's top Osteopaths.
He has held international teaching positions having tutored in Australia and Mumbai, India and is currently clinical supervisor and tutor at The London School of Osteopathy.
He has special interests in functional biomechanics, sports, post-op rehabilitation, along with chronic pain and corporate health services, He has post grad training in dry needling and clinical Pilates.
Andrew believes in actively involving his patients to achieve their goals and finds a combination of manual therapy and strength and conditioning vital for patient’s recovery from injury.
Anna has seventeen years experience since gaining her Masters in Osteopathy and has worked extensively in the NHS and sports clinics treating all ages from new-borns to old age including many office workers, sports people and those practicing martial arts.
She combines a structural and holistic approach using joint manipulations, soft tissue and muscle energy techniques with gentle visceral osteopathy, cranial osteopathy and fascial techniques. She has a special interest in the spine, pelvis, abdomen and diaphragm.
She is passionate in giving her patients the best care and getting them back to doing the things they love as soon as possible.